If you are on the hunt for a reliable vertical smoker that won’t break the bank, the Realcook Vertical 17 Inch Steel Charcoal Smoker deserves a close look. This guide compares it with three other popular models from Pit Boss, Masterbuilt, and Realcook’s own larger version to help you choose the right smoker for your outdoor cooking needs. For more outdoor cooking gear, check out our weber Master-Touch charcoal grill review.
Pros
- Versatile cooking options from smoking to grilling to baking
- Large capacity with 636 sq in of cooking space
- Portable and easy to store with disassembly into 4 parts
- Precise temperature control with built-in thermometer and bottom vent
- Easy assembly and cleaning with removable ash collector
Cons
- Alloy steel construction may be less durable than stainless steel in harsh weather
- Some users report temperature fluctuations in windy conditions requiring attention
- Assembly instructions could be more detailed for first-time users
The Realcook 20 Inch Charcoal BBQ Smoker Grill is a versatile vertical smoker designed for outdoor cooking enthusiasts who want flexibility in one unit. It can function as a smoker, grill, fire pit, or even a steamer, making it suitable for backyard parties, camping trips, or beach cookouts. With a large 636 square inch cooking surface, it easily handles whole turkeys, slabs of ribs, and large cuts of meat for feeding a crowd.
Standout features include the multi-layered design with a latch locking system that secures the unit for various cooking methods. The built-in thermometer and special bottom damper allow precise temperature control, while the two access doors let you check food or add charcoal without losing heat. The porcelain-enameled water pan adds moisture and infuses a deep smoky flavor into your meats, delivering tender results every time.
Build quality is solid with alloy steel construction, though it is not as heavy-duty as stainless steel. The smoker is designed to be portable, disassembling into four parts that fit easily in a car trunk. Assembly takes about 30-45 minutes, and the removable ash collector makes cleanup quick. The 32-pound weight is manageable for one person to move around the yard.
One potential drawback is that the alloy steel may show wear over time if left exposed to the elements, so storage in a dry place is recommended. Some users note that temperature control can be challenging in windy conditions, requiring regular monitoring. Additionally, the assembly instructions could be clearer for first-time users, but online resources and videos help.
Overall, the Realcook 20 Inch Charcoal BBQ Smoker Grill offers excellent value for its price, combining versatility, large capacity, and portability. It is a great choice for beginners and experienced cooks alike who want a reliable smoker and grill in one. With proper care, it delivers consistent performance for many outdoor cooking adventures.
Buying Guide: What to Look for in a Vertical Smoker
Cooking Space
The amount of cooking area you need depends on how often you host gatherings. The Realcook 17 inch model offers 453 square inches across two racks, while the larger Realcook 20 inch provides 636 square inches. The Pit Boss 3-Series gives you 880 square inches on four racks, and the Masterbuilt 30-inch delivers 710 square inches. Consider your typical batch size before deciding. For more on outdoor cooking setups, visit our Outdoor Cooking category.
Temperature Control
Consistent temperature is key for smoking. The Realcook 17 inch uses a built-in thermometer and adjustable air supply for manual control. The Pit Boss model features Wi-Fi and Bluetooth connectivity, letting you monitor and adjust from your phone. Masterbuilt’s digital controls allow you to set time and temperature up to 275°F. If precise control matters to you, a digital model may be worth the investment.
Build Quality and Durability
Materials and construction affect longevity. The Realcook smokers use porcelain-enameled water and charcoal pans, along with heat-resistant bakelite handles. The Pit Boss includes a removable grease tray and rear wheels for easy movement. Masterbuilt features a removable water bowl and grease tray for simple cleanup. For insights on enamel cookware, see our lodge essential enamel dutch oven review.
Versatility
Vertical smokers can do more than just smoke. The Realcook 17 inch can also grill, steam, bake, braise, and roast thanks to its two access doors and latch locking system. The Realcook 20 inch adds a bottom damper and ash collector for better airflow control. If you want a multi-functional cooker, these charcoal models offer flexibility. For another portable option, check the weber smokey joe grill review.
Final Thoughts
After comparing these four vertical smokers, we recommend the Realcook Vertical 17 Inch Steel Charcoal Smoker for budget-conscious cooks who want a solid, versatile smoker without digital frills. For those who prefer remote monitoring and a larger cooking area, the Pit Boss 3-Series WiFi & Bluetooth is a strong upgrade that brings modern convenience to your backyard.
Frequently Asked Questions
How does the Realcook 17 inch smoker compare to the 20 inch version?
The 20 inch model offers 636 square inches of cooking space versus 453 on the 17 inch, and includes a bottom damper for better airflow. Both share the same multi-functional design, but the larger version is better for bigger gatherings. For compact smoking, the 17 inch remains a top choice in 2026.
Can I use the Realcook smoker for grilling as well?
Yes, the latch locking system allows you to adjust the height of the charcoal pan, transforming it into a grill. You can also use it for steaming, baking, and roasting. This versatility makes it a great all-in-one outdoor cooker. For a dedicated compact grill, see the weber jumbo joe 22 review.
Is the Pit Boss smoker worth the extra cost?
If you value convenience and larger capacity, the Pit Boss 3-Series with Wi-Fi and Bluetooth is worth the investment. It offers 880 square inches and precise digital control, ideal for frequent smokers who want to monitor cooks remotely. For occasional use on a budget, the Realcook 17 inch delivers excellent value.
How easy is it to assemble the Realcook smoker?
Assembly typically takes 30 to 45 minutes, and the smoker can be disassembled into four parts for easy transport. The instructions are straightforward, and most users find the process manageable with basic tools. This portability is a plus for camping or tailgating.
